Sarah & Ian Hoffman

Building a culture of kindness. One book at a time.
Menu

  • Home
  • Books
    • Jacob’s New Dress
    • Jacob’s Room to Choose
    • Jacob’s School Play
    • Jacob’s Missing Book
  • About Us
  • Events
    • Events
    • Our Presentations
  • Press
    • Media Kit
    • Stories by Us
    • Stories about Us
  • Fight Book Bans
  • Contact

The “My Son is Gay” Phenomenon

November 4, 2010 by Sarah

Yesterday I read an essay by mom blogger Cop’s Wife, entitled My Son Is Gay. It’s a fantastic essay, about the blogger’s son, Boo, who dressed as Daphne for Halloween. It says most of what I’ve been saying on my blog for more than a year about acceptance—but she’s funnier and smarter than I am, so you should definitely read it. I made a comment on her blog, and signed up to receive future comments by email, because I take a personal and professional interest in how people respond to stories about gender-nonconforming boys.

By this evening, there are 14,000 comments on the site (all of which have appeared in my inbox…I might think twice next time I sign up for that function). Maybe I’ve just been sheltered from the viral blog phenomenon, but I’m completely blown away. There are 14,000 people who care enough to comment on this woman’s boy in a skirt (probably more by the time you get this post from me and check out her website)! Most of these people are enthusiastically supportive (and only a few tell her she’s sinning, or ruining her son’s life, or using other assorted scare tactics). And this is what really blows me away: how much support we have. How many people will jump to defend a boy who’s different. How strongly people feel about not bullying boys who make choices like Boo did. I really had no idea.

So please read it, pass it around, talk about it with your families and friends, and celebrate how many supporters we have in the world!

Share

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: "gender variant" "gender nonconforming" "gender spectrum" "parenting", "My Son is Gay"

Jacob's New Dress

by Sarah and Ian Hoffman

"Hopeful and affirming." - Kirkus Review

Buy an autographed copy.

Comments

  1. starkravingmadmommy says

    November 4, 2010 at 7:53 pm

    It was a great post. I think one of the reasons it went viral was the accompanying photo of that adorable kid rockin’ the Daphne costume. However, it’s hard to know whether Boo is going to be happy, later on, about that photo having gone viral.

    • shoffman says

      November 4, 2010 at 10:41 pm

      It does worry me, putting a photo of your kid online. I think you’re right–it’s a big draw, but it also feels like a big risk to me. Not just violating that child’s privacy, but potentially his safety. It was an awesome post, though.

  2. Sarah Buttenwieser says

    November 5, 2010 at 3:57 am

    I thought frankly it wasn’t particularly that great. For whatever reason (probably her tone, which wasn’t so funny, but a little snarky) it ‘hit’ & yet you or Accepting Dad or I have said the same thing for eons. She really didn’t go beyond the ‘i’m letting him be daphne, in fact i’m making him b/c i paid $$ for the costume’. to me, not such empathic parenting. & not really looking head on at what if. which at five, she doesn’t have to!

  3. elle says

    November 5, 2010 at 5:11 am

    I’d love it if you wouldn’t truncate your RSS feed… is this possible?

    • shoffman says

      November 6, 2010 at 10:56 am

      On a more administrative topic, what do other people think about receiving the whole blog post by email vs. a truncated post that leads you to the website?

  4. shoffman says

    November 5, 2010 at 9:15 am

    Now over 20,000 comments, and more than 1 million hits, in 2 days.

  5. Meganne F says

    November 5, 2010 at 9:51 am

    I had a couple of fb friends post that story, so I am guessing that it hit a nerve. I’m not in her same situation, but I liked her whole attitude (even though it was snarky) about people/parents needing to focus maybe more on their own kids and not so much on perceived “issues” of other kids. Maybe if we project that as parents, the next generation will grow up to respect other people more and not be so judgmental. (This discussion is definitely part of a broader societal direction that scares me.)

  6. mark says

    November 5, 2010 at 9:56 am

    Sarah, you could read it as her forcing him to continue with it, or you could see it as her pushing him past giving in to his fear.

  7. earwicga says

    November 5, 2010 at 1:42 pm

    I’m glad to hear that the comments were overwhelmingly positive!

    Also happy to have found your blog – looking forward to having a read through.

    • shoffman says

      November 5, 2010 at 2:39 pm

      Welcome! Glad to have you here.

  8. Hartley Steiner says

    November 5, 2010 at 5:15 pm

    I actually enjoy snarky-writing and thought the post was good, especially about how she wasn’t worried about the other women’s kid growing up to be an actual ninja, “so back off”.

    What I think has hit a nerve – or perhaps what SHOULD hit a nerve – is the fact that this child was being bullied, teased, and having his gender identity/sexualy orientation questioned by ADULTS.

    My son has many challenges in life, and the one group of people who are quick to judge, quick to condem and quick to blame, are his peers’ parents. Adults, not kids.

    I am sincerely hoping that the judgemental-mom crowd out there gets that they should let kids be kids. Whatever that looks like.

  9. shoffman says

    November 8, 2010 at 11:54 am

    Now there are over 30,000 comments!

  10. shoffman says

    November 8, 2010 at 12:27 pm

    Oops, I meant 40,000!

Testimonials

“Working with Sarah and Ian Hoffman was a blessing. They were organized and collaborative in every detail. Once they began sharing, the crowd was rapt with curiosity and empathy. With warmth, humor, and disarming honesty they invited us to explore gender diversity and inclusion in ways that rang with authenticity, hope, and practicality. People left feeling both challenged and resolute for the work ahead—with new language for addressing complex topics and renewed joy. If you are considering inviting Sarah and Ian, expect a generous partnership and a revelatory Q&A.”

—Rev. Victor H. Floyd
Calvary Presbyterian Church

“Sarah & Ian’s visits to our class help us to cultivate an environment where students feel safe to express themselves, explore their identities, and appreciate and support others.”

—Anjali Ramisetti
First Grade Teacher
Katherine Delmar Burke School

“Sarah and Ian were so thoughtful in providing just-right content for our kindergarteners all the way up to our older students. Their loving and honest stories, easy back-and-forth with one another, and humorous delivery of a delicate topic made this sensitive, yet oh-so-critical topic digestible and relatable. This is a conversation that I hope students, teachers, and parents will continue to have with more ease thanks to the Hoffmans. I’m so grateful to them for sharing their gift of their family’s journey, and their beautiful storytelling, with our entire school community.”

—Kristine Keane
School Social Worker
George Peabody School

“The first time I heard Sarah & Ian tell their story, I was in awe of them. Their loving, unconditional acceptance of their child is a model every parent should see. What a lucky child Sam is to get to grow up with Sarah & Ian as his parents!”

—Susan Rahman, MA
Faculty, Sociology, Psychology, and Behavioral Science, College of Marin

“Sarah & Ian have a unique ability to capture the joys and challenges of raising a gender-nonconforming child. Their natural ability as storytellers, combined with their insightful reflections on their own journey as parents, make them compelling speakers for a diverse range of audiences. Balancing humorous anecdotes with poignant realism, they build awareness, understanding, and acceptance of families and children navigating this challenging terrain.”

—Joel Baum
Gender Spectrum Education and Training

“Sarah & Ian’s willingness to share the story of their family with my students has opened up new dialogue and understanding of children with diverse expressions of gender. The research they have completed with other families with children who cross gender “boxes” has been invaluable in helping teachers understand the perspectives of parents and caregivers and how we can support them as educators. We always appreciate their openness and willingness to share time with us!”

—Tracy Burt
Faculty, Child Development and Family Studies Department, City College of San Francisco

Buy the Books

Jacob's Missing Book

Buy at Green Apple Books

Jacob's School Play: Starring He, She & They!

Buy at Green Apple Books

Jacob's Room to Choose

Buy at Green Apple Books

Jacob's New Dress

Buy at Green Apple Books

Upcoming Events

Check out our upcoming events to see if we’ll be heading to your area.

Join our mailing list!
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Copyright © 2026 by Sarah and Ian Hoffman • All Rights Reserved • Site design by Makeworthy Media